top of page

There Are Two Historic Oak Trees on the Green – One of Them, an Impostor

Philip Thibodeau
4 hours ago
5 min read
Marker for the pin oak at the north end of the green. The tree it marks is, in fact, not a Constitution Oak.  PHILIP THIBODEAU PHOTOS
Marker for the pin oak at the north end of the green. The tree it marks is, in fact, not a Constitution Oak. PHILIP THIBODEAU PHOTOS

There are two oak trees growing on Southington’s town green. One is located at the green’s southwest corner, across from the Freemasons' Friendship Lodge number 33. It is a white oak, with rounded leaves that look like a puzzle pieces, and about 50 years old. The other lies at the northeast corner of the green, close to the intersection of Center Street and Main Street. It is a pin oak, with sharp, pointy leaves, and appears to be roughly the same age as the other tree.

 

Both trees have historical markers below them. But of the two, one has authentic historical connections – while the other one is an impostor.

 

The Charter Oak

 

Most people in Connecticut have heard of the Charter Oak. The Charter Oak Bridge in Hartford gets its name from the tree, and an engraved representation of it can be found on the Connecticut state quarter.

 

The legends surrounding the Charter Oak are colorful. According to traditions preserved by early European settlers, the tree, a massive white oak growing on the top of a hill in Hartford, was a meeting place for native Americans. It so impressed the settlers with its beauty and its size that even as the surrounding forests were relentlessly logged, this one specimen was spared.

 

In 1686, the King of England, James II, tried to consolidate the New England colonies into a single entity called the Dominion of New England. To fulfill his aim he needed to revoke their founding charters. He attempted to do so by having a colonial governor, Sir Edmund Andros, go around to each colonial capitol and confiscate its founding document.

 

When the colonists in Hartford got wind of his plan, they devised their own scheme. Arrangements were made with Andros to meet in a tavern where the document would be handed over. But just as the surrender was about to occur, all the candles in the room suddenly went out and a mysterious figure whisked the paper away. That figure, Joseph Wadsworth, ran off to the great oak with the charter and hid it in a hollow in the trunk of the tree, to prevent it from being found.

 

Andros never did get possession of the document, and two years later, all plans for consolidation of the colonies were scrapped.

 

That was the event that gave the Charter Oak its name.

 

In 1856, the ancient tree blew down in a windstorm. At the time of its demise, it was approximately 600 years old.

 

Yet while the tree no longer survives, its descendants live on. Locals collected the acorns it dropped in the last year of its life and planted them in cities and town across Connecticut. When they sprouted, they produced what are called Charter Oak scions. As the scions matured, they generated their own acorns, which have also been gathered and planted.

 

In 1976, as part of the centennial celebrations, the State Forestry Service distributed second generation Charter Oak descendants to the state’s towns. In July of that year, Park Superintendent Dominic Mongillo, with the assistance of two members of the Conservation Commission, Madaline Brunelli and Bob Kuchta, planted the year-old sapling on the southwest corner of the green. Photographer Craig Baggott of The Observer was on hand for the event and the picture he took was published in the paper on July 15:

 

The Observer, July 15, 1976, front page. SCREENSHOT SOUTHINGTON LIBRARY ARCHIVE
The Observer, July 15, 1976, front page. SCREENSHOT SOUTHINGTON LIBRARY ARCHIVE

The tree still grows there today, with a marker that indicates its identity:


 

If you can find an acorn from the tree, you can grow your Charter Oak scion – a great-grandchild of the famous tree. (As a practical benefit, its acorns will provide black bears with a healthy alternative to trash from your trash can.)


Grandchild of the Charter Oak, growing on the southwest corner of the green.
Grandchild of the Charter Oak, growing on the southwest corner of the green.

The Constitution Oak

 

Connecticut has another kind of historic oak tree - so-called Constitution Oaks.

 

Like the Charter Oak, Constitution Oaks have their origins in a failed attempt to reorganize state government - though it was a much more recent one. In 1901, Connecticut voters passed a measure calling for the state to hold a constitutional convention. The burning issue at the time was the perceived unfairness of a system that gave all towns and cities the same number of state representatives, regardless of their population. Delegates to the convention, which was held the following year, developed a proposal that would give larger communities more representation. However, voters overwhelmingly rejected the plan.

 

In the end, it was the state’s tree population rather than its human population that saw the greatest impact from the meeting. Each of the convention delegates was presented with a pin oak seedling to take home to their community. Southington’s pin oak was given to Probate Judge Marcus Holcomb, a man who would later go on to become Connecticut’s 66th governor, and was the namesake for the now-defunct Holcomb Elementary School.

 

The oak tree on the northeast corner of the green has a marker below it which identifies it as a Constitution Oak. It reads, “THIS IS A CONSTITUTION OAK PRESENTED TO THE HON. M. H. HOLCOMB, A DELEGATE TO THE CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION IN HARTFORD, 1902, MARKED BY HANNAH WOODRUFF CHAPTER D.A.R., 1828.” (See header for picture.)


This is the tree in question:



The tree, however, cannot be a Constitution Oak. For one, it is a white oak, like the Charter Oak, not a pin oak.

 

Second, it is too small to be 124 years old. According to Glenn Dryer, who surveyed the state’s Constitution Oaks in 2002, the average circumference of a Constitution Oak now is about ten feet. The one on the green has a circumference of about seven feet.

 

Third, Dryer found records indicating that the Constitution Oak was planted at Lewis High School. Lewis was the town’s original high school building, located on the hill behind First Congregational, where the Southington Housing Authority now is. The structure was demolished in 1967.

 

Finally, Dryer listed the status of Southington’s Constitution Oak as ‘dead.’

 

The conclusion is inescapable. The marker for the Constitution Oak is authentic and the tree it sits in front of is an oak. However, the oak tree on the green is not a Constitution Oak.

 

How then did the marker get moved to the green and set before the wrong tree? We assume no mischief was involved, and the mislabeling is, of course, quite harmless. But for the sake of historical curiosity, the Southington Outsider will continue to look into this story until we find the answer.


Many thanks to Katy Hanlon for finding and sharing the Dryer post.













Tops_Logo_Final_OL.png

© 2026 The Southington Outsider        Logo image by CTDroneSource 

 

We pledge that all writing and images produced by staff of The Southington Outsider are created by humans, not by AI. We recommend, but cannot guarantee, that user-submitted Opinions, Tributes and Posters adhere to this policy. 

 

The Southington Outsider does not collect, use or share any individually identifiable data related to your browsing of this site. Wix, our hosting platform, has a separate privacy policy. 

bottom of page